Many collectors and casual savers pass through rolls of pennies without realizing some coins in everyday change can be worth far more than face value. This guide lists the Top 10 rare Lincoln pennies still in circulation and explains what to look for when you check your change.
Top 10 Rare Lincoln Pennies Still in Circulation – Check Your Change
Below are ten Lincoln penny varieties you might still find in circulation. Each entry includes identifying details and a quick note on typical values for circulated examples. Values change with condition and market demand.
1. 1909-S VDB
Features designer Victor David Brenner initials VDB on the reverse near the rim. The San Francisco minted 1909-S VDB is rare in circulation and commands high collector interest.
Look for bold VDB initials and clear detail on Lincoln and wheat stalks. Low-grade pieces still sell for significantly more than face value.
2. 1909-S
Different from the VDB variant, this dime shows the mintmark and no VDB or the initials placed differently. Early 20th-century strikes from San Francisco are scarce in everyday change.
Even worn examples are collectible and can command notable premiums.
3. 1914-D
The 1914 Denver Lincoln wheat penny is a key date and very scarce in circulation. It often shows weak strikes and heavy wear due to age.
Collectors prize well-struck examples; circulated coins still outrank face value by a wide margin.
4. 1922 No D (Plain)
Some 1922 pennies appear to lack a Denver D mintmark due to poor striking. These “Plain” 1922s are unusual and sought after when genuine and well-documented.
Distinguish from heavily worn or cleaned coins by checking die features and consulting references.
5. 1931-S
The 1931 San Francisco Lincoln penny is another scarce date that occasionally surfaces. Look for sharp details and a clear S mintmark.
Even in low grades, this coin will typically sell for multiple times face value.
6. 1955 Doubled Die Obverse
This famous error shows strong doubling on Lincoln’s profile and the date. The doubling is obvious around the date and the words IN GOD WE TRUST.
Not every worn coin with odd features is this error—confirm with magnification and reference photos.
7. 1943 Copper Penny
Most 1943 cents were struck in steel; a small number were mistakenly struck in bronze (copper). These coins are highly prized and can be valuable when authentic.
Testing and expert verification are essential because modern counterfeits and alterations exist.
8. 1969-S Doubled Die Obverse
Another doubled die error, the 1969-S shows doubling on Lincoln’s profile and the date. It is less common in circulation and attracts error collectors.
Use a loupe to confirm the doubling before assuming rarity.
9. 1879 Indian Head Variety (Related History)
Older pattern and early cents are rare in circulation and occasionally turn up in estate finds. While not a Lincoln cent, knowing early cent types helps when sorting old coins.
If you find an obviously older design in a mixed lot of pennies, set it aside for expert review.
10. 2009-S Lincoln Bicentennial Doubled Die or Proof Strikes
2009 had multiple commemorative designs, and some minting errors or prooflike specimens escaped into circulation. They are collectible and worth checking.
Look for unusually sharp details or polarization that suggests a proof finish.
How to Spot Rare Lincoln Pennies in Your Change
Use a few simple tools and steps to screen coins quickly. A loupe or magnifier, good light, and a basic reference image set make a big difference.
- Check dates and mintmarks first; these identify key years.
- Look for doubling, misplaced mintmarks, or missing marks.
- Note metal color: a 1943 bronze will be copper-toned, unlike the usual steel cents.
Condition, Grading, and Value Basics
Condition greatly affects value. Coins are graded from Poor to Mint State, and even a rare date in poor condition is often worth more than face value.
If you think you found a valuable piece, avoid cleaning it. Cleaning can reduce collectible value dramatically.
One circulated 1955 doubled die was discovered in a small town bank deposit and later sold at auction for thousands of dollars. Doubling is visible without specialized equipment in many cases.
Quick Checklist Before You Sell or Submit a Coin
- Confirm date and mintmark with a magnifier.
- Compare to reliable photos of known varieties.
- Do not clean the coin; photos or scans are better for initial valuation.
- For suspected high-value finds, seek a professional grading service.
Small Real-World Case Study
A cashier found a worn 1955 doubled die while counting a register roll. The cashier posted clear photos to a coin forum, where members confirmed the error. After professional authentication, the coin sold privately to a collector for a four-figure sum.
This case shows how ordinary circulation can still produce valuable discoveries and the importance of community identification before selling.
Where to Get Help
If you find a coin you believe is rare, consult trusted resources such as the American Numismatic Association, reputable coin dealers, or a third-party grading service for authentication.
Forums and local coin clubs are also useful for preliminary identification and advice.
Checking your change is free and can be rewarding. Keep a magnifier nearby, learn the key dates and errors, and set aside any penny that looks unusual. You might be surprised what turns up in your pocket.